From my experience, producers with no prior knowledge of music creation seem to pick up Logic way faster than almost any other DAW.

This seems to be primarily down to the spacious, clear layout and module arrangement. The developers clearly put a enormous amount of effort into the spacial design, making it not only highly intuitive, but rapid and responsive. One example here is loop-based production. Ableton is one of the fastest, most practical DAWs out there.

Furthermore, you can optimise almost anything according to your unique workflow. Ableton Live 10 currently comes with 17 instruments and 59 audio effects.

Logic Pro X on the other hand, boasts 24 instruments and a whopping 70 built-in effects. It offers two main oscillators plus a third sub oscillator which you can use to shape, bend, squeeze and morph hundreds of wavetables to your hearts content. These wavetables are derived from classic, synthetic or real-instrument waveforms. Wavetable also offers two filters, endless modulation options, presented with a gorgeous, easy-to-use interface.

Not only that, but it sounds magnificent. Each of these plugins comes with a ton of presets, giving you a vast amount of creative possibilities.

When it comes to virtual instruments, one of Logics most prized possessions is the iconic synth Alchemy. Alchemy is a disgustingly powerful synthesizer packaged with over unique sounds and an expansive array of on-board parameters and controls. It also has multiple sound-generating engines, including additive, spectral, formant, granular and virtual analog. Plus, it can act as a sampler instrument for warping importing sound files. Other personal highlights of Logic instruments are ES2 another wavetable synth and Sculpture a unique physical modelling instrument based on real-world glass, wood and other material sounds.

Click here to view the full list of effects in all their glory. On top of that, if you were to purely compare the numbers, Logic has more instruments that Ableton. This activates quick swipe behaviors, allowing you to create and edit comps with incredible fluidity and precision. If live performance is your primary reason for searching for the right DAW, Ableton should be on the top of your list.

At the end of the day, neither of these DAWs is objectively superior. Linear arrangement refers to the work format of the app. Rather than loop-oriented arrangement which is well-suited for live gigs , linear arrangement is the go-to format for producers who are writing new music in the studio.

In its most basic sense, it means writing music from left to right. Thus, how do they compare in this feature? It is simple, clear, and easily understandable. The track headers which include the track name, volume, a pan knob, and the mute or solo button are arranged in a row down the left side of the workspace.

This is well designed and logical to the eye given the general progression from left to right on the screen. In addition, the looping process is simple and the flexibility and short-cutting that is possible on Logic Pro is undeniably impressive.

It is an incredible asset though one can do all of these functions in Ableton, it is arguably less clearly laid-out.

One of the few downsides of Logic is the lack of speed in its workflow when compared to Ableton. Where Ableton allows for an incredible amount of speedy shortcuts, Logic sometimes requires a few more steps.

A unique strength of Logic, however, is its emphasis on mixing and mastering. This makes it the preferred option for film composers and those who are prioritizing the mixing process over the sound design process.

The setup, with its track headers to the right of the workspace, is perhaps initially disorienting to newcomers but after a very short period of acclimatization, the format starts to impress. Live contains an equally strong MIDI and Audio recording function, and an excellent automation process. In addition, Ableton Live is the more streamlined, efficient approach to music production. With its extensive shortcuts and multiple avenues for achieving one goal, Ableton Live will be better suited to producers who like to create quickly with little hassle.

Logic, on the other hand, might be better suited to the more leisurely producer. Live also allows the producer to move to any part of the composition while maintaining the continuity of the song.

In other words, Ableton Live jumps playback to the desired point without skipping a beat. Though this may seem like a small thing, it is one of the many unique qualities of the Ableton platform. This allows multiple producers on the same local network to link their devices across a range of hardware and apps and collaborate while keeping in time.

This can create a fun and highly unique production experience. Thus, with the exception of Ableton Link, there is very little to divide the arrangement views of Ableton Live and Logic and ultimately your choice depends upon your own requirements and preferences. Aside from the preferred design and layout which is completely subjective , Live might be better for a more streamlined approach perhaps this is better for electronic producers , while Logic is more suitable for a beginner due to its easy learning curve or a more traditional composer.

It is now the standard piece of software for live DJing and dance music production. Its grid-based arrangement of columns, each containing a variety of clip slots for each audio or MIDI input, is innovative and highly intuitive allowing the producer to make tracks on the fly.

In addition, the Ableton Live Session View allows the producer to play any of these loops in perfect sync with the others.

Ableton Live also contains the highly useful Follow Actions button which allows the producer to automate the launching of multiple loops in a variety of arrangements. This is unique to Live and has yet to be copied. This contains a Session View which has been seamlessly imported, improved, and expanded into the Logic Pro X interface.

The loop table functions very similarly to the Ableton Live loop setup. The only major difference is the ability of Logic to have the Session View and the linear arrangement open at the same time.

Thus, if you are a producer looking for software to perform live with, Ableton is probably your best bet. That being said, if you are familiar with the Logic interface and prefer the functions of the Logic platform, there is not enough of a difference in quality to justify spending a huge amount more on Ableton Live.

Thus, due to the broadly similar quality between both services, the choice is really determined by the overall feel and design of the function. If you prioritize design over functionality and prefer or are familiar through GarageBand on iOS with the Logic platform, this is probably the better version. In addition, the Follow Actions function gives Ableton Live a slight edge. Beginning in , as Notator Logic, Logic has since fine-tuned and expanded the capabilities of this function.

The score editor is particularly useful for traditional classical composers and film score composers. This exemplifies how Logic is perhaps better suited to traditional production as opposed to electronic music.

In addition, the MIDI quantization, transformation, and simple editing functions are innovative and staggeringly intuitive. And if you have Suite edition or bought Max for Live separately , you can get tons of free Max for Live MIDI devices — from chord generators to experimental polyrhythm sequencers.

As for Audio recording and editing, it truly depends on your priorities. Logic is better suited for those producers who are seeking to record live bands, vocals, and organic instrumentation due to its emphasis on the EQ, pitch correction, and mixing functions.

This is good for producers working with multiple takes. In conclusion, once again, if you prioritize a speedy workflow and electronic music production over traditional production and organic instrumental recording, Ableton Live may be for you. Alternatively, if you want to replicate the conditions of an actual recording studio, Logic might be your best bet. The instrument and effect libraries for both platforms are comprehensive and, with time, have become exceedingly impressive.

Ableton Live has 17 fantastic virtual instruments not including the extraordinarily extensive Max for Live add-on. The Intro Edition has just 4 and the Standard Edition has 6. They allow for a more experimental and boundless range of sounds. Whether this is an issue is obviously completely subjective.

There are also lots of hardware gear controllers so you can program, control and automate parameters of your outboard synths and drum machines without touching them. Moreover, this add-on gives you the unique ability to create your own instruments and effects.

This is unavailable in Logic, and is another example of the endless creative freedom of Ableton.

Logic pro x or ableton live 10 free -

The extra packs available for download sound great but many of these are only free to download if you have purchased the Suite version of Ableton Live. Frustratingly this happens fairly often, which casts a bit of a shadow over what is otherwise a very powerful and comprehensive application.

Ableton Live has been considerably more stable in all previous versions which is clearly very important due to its heavy use for live performance where the possibility of a crash can be devastating to a show.

As a side note, we have found that there has been some issues with Ableton Live 10 crashing and causing elevated CPU in the initial Live 10 update but these issues appear to have been fixed in a more recent update. Both Logic Pro and Ableton Live are capable of auto-saving in the background.

In the event of a crash the application will give the option to either revert to the last auto-save or the last manual save. Tech Drums Lite Pack. Tech Drums Full Pack. Ableton Bible Free Sound Library. Vintage House Sample Pack. Logic Pro is for Apple Mac only. This is likely the reason why they can afford to sell the application at such a competitive price compared to other DAWs because a mac is required to run the software. Logic is similar to every other traditional DAW in the way that it has a linear style of arrangement, mapped to the time domain.

Much like Logic Pro, Ableton Live also has a time-based arrangement-view but also benefits from session-view. Session view was how Ableton Live started as a program and is what makes it such a powerful tool for live performance. Session view allows DJs and performers to jam and experiment with clips, loops, and arrangement to quickly get ideas, concepts or entire compositions into Ableton Live.

These ideas can then either be re-performed using session view or recorded into arrangement view to be exported as a final composition. It could be argued that versions of Ableton Live prior to Live 10 could have done with a face-lift, which is essentially exactly what happened in Live This ensures all of Ableton Lives devices follow the same theme and in my opinion this also makes them more intuitive to learn and navigate because many of the parameters of a device can be found on multiple devices.

Both DAWs are extremely feature rich. Here is a list of some of the key-points taken from both of them. Ableton is capable of doing this as well but it is not a default feature and requires an options text file hack. Ableton definitely has its advantages for electronic music which utilizes heavier use of audio manipulation and sampling in particular.

However, from personal experience we feel that Ableton Live is the DAW of choice for fast idea-generation and a speedy workflow. It pays dividends to learn the shortcuts for each application or look at getting a keyboard overlay to help you. Keyboard overlays are especially useful if you plan on using both apps and will be jumping between them on a weekly basis. In Ableton, this sort of task would require very little extra work from the user.

For this reason, Ableton Live is great for creating complex live sets with tempo changes and is also a great tool for creating studio DJ mixes and radio show podcasts. However, many Live users spend most of their time creating music in the Arrangement View, which is excellently served by its nimble navigation, quick UI, seamless automation, and generally obstacle-free approach. Section-defining Arrangement Markers, scissors, glue, erase. In practice, though, linear music arrangement in any DAW is a delight.

The winner of the linear arrangement in Logic Pro. The groundbreaking non-linear Session View clip recording and launching interface from Ableton Live took a few years to alter the world of music technology. Still, it established the de facto standard for laptop DJing and dance music creation and placed the Berlin-based business on the map.

This apparently benign Clip View control panel allows producers and live performers to automate and randomize clip-launching within Scenes, something no other DAW can accomplish. The winner of the loop arrangement is Ableton. Alchemy is the most obviously powerful of the two, taking in additive, granular, and analog-style synthesis, with four simultaneous inputs, gobs of filters, and abundant effects.

It was formerly an expensive third-party instrument until Apple purchased its developer, Camel Audio. On the other hand, wavetable is a two-oscillator plus sub wavetable synth with over well-crafted wavetables onboard, two filters, extensive modulation possibilities, and an extremely user-friendly interface and workflow. Those two elements are essential for us. These new additions have been included to an outstanding lineup of distortion, dynamics, equalization the integrated Channel EQ is particularly noticeable , reverb, delay, modulation, and other effect types, giving you everything you need to finish your mixing job.

Live differs from Logic in that it gives equal weight to sound design and mixing processors. Depending on your major plugin requirements, this round of our face-off might go either way: Live is best used for sound design, and Logic is best used for mixing.

Effects category is a draw! However, there are significant variances…. On the other hand, Live is about as lean and mean as DAWs come, with its less stratified, comparably approachable interface and the speed with which a seasoned user can jet about its Session and Arrange Views, Sample Editor, and Piano Roll is a special part of the software.

Back over the pond, Logic is known for its unrivaled key commands scheme, which allows users to customize a huge number of shortcuts to fit their own tactile demands, no matter how bizarre.

Both companies have dedicated controllers for their DAWs. DAW workflow, in our opinion, is all about getting things done as quickly as possible. By that criteria, Live is the clear winner in this round of the competition. Overall, there is no objectively better option. Budget is obviously important to all of us, but purchasing a DAW is an investment in your future. On top of this, this may mean you have to spend money on a second DAW in the future if you rushed your decision. Opening a new DAW can be an incredibly daunting experience.

You are instantly met with an array of windows, menus and controls, with absolutely no idea where to get started. Each DAW has their own separate learning curve. Some offer a more linear, beginner-friendly interface, while others definitely take some time to get used to. To help out beginners and often even advanced producers both Ableton and Logic Pro offer on-board explanations of each control and production module. In Ableton, simply hover your mouse over something and a brief description will appear in the bottom left corner of the screen.

From my experience, producers with no prior knowledge of music creation seem to pick up Logic way faster than almost any other DAW. This seems to be primarily down to the spacious, clear layout and module arrangement. The developers clearly put a enormous amount of effort into the spacial design, making it not only highly intuitive, but rapid and responsive. One example here is loop-based production.

Ableton is one of the fastest, most practical DAWs out there. Furthermore, you can optimise almost anything according to your unique workflow.

.

While those who have been working on Logic Pro will tell you that it is hands down the best DAW, Ableton Live loyalists would beg to differ! While these DAWs used to be very different, they have gotten much more similar in recent years now that Logic Pro includes a live looping view and a much more similar sampler and drum machine.

The lines are now a bit more blurred and figuring out the difference between the two requires a bit of explaination. Ableton Live and Logic Pro both include future minor updates for free when buying their software e.

Major versions of the software e. Version 12 will require an upgrade fee, but these are generally far cheaper than buying the product from scratch. For those who are using a DAW for the first time, the visual layout of Logic Pro is easy to navigate through. It follows a horizontal timeline. The clearly defined icons in the sound library help you ftee quick decisions so you can start writing or playing music efficiently. Ableton Live offers a similar Arrangement view. One of the key differences between the two is the horizontal Master track offered by Ableton Live, which lets you drop audio effects such as an eq to your master track.

On Logic Pro, your master channel is vertical and on the left on your screen. Since both offer similar layouts and features, it would be difficult to pick one over the other. However, when it comes to a more efficient workflow, Ableton Live would be a better choice.

Ableton Live was developed in by Bernt Roggendorf and Gerhard Behles with the additional objective of it being a live performance tool apart from recording capabilities.

The Session view is grid-based. The Session view also has provisions for a mixer with individual faders and knobs to control volume, reverb, and delay. With its But the workflow is frer as smooth as it is on Ableton Live. To make any changes to your mix, you will have ablehon manually select the tracks vree make adjustments individually.

So while in theory, this is a fun new ablrton that lets you play around with the arrangement before you decide on what you would like to record, it does not make a lot of sense if you were to use this DAW for a live performance.

Logic Pro appears to have been developed in a very efficient manner for the only OS it supports, which is Mac. I do hope this will get resolved in the near future through minor updates. Ableton Live offers a dedicated controller, the Push 2, for an additional cost. Since this has been designed specifically for the DAW, users have praised its efficiency as well as its intuitiveness. Although there is no dedicated control surface for Logic Proyou can download the Logic Remote app on your iPhone or iPad and control certain parameters with it.

You can open software instruments and use your device as a MIDI keyboard or ,ogic step sequencer. The remote lets logic pro x or ableton live 10 free access live loops as well. But one of the major drawbacks is that at the end of the day, it is still an app and cannot replace hardware.

Users have also complained of the devices disconnecting when left idle. Although the Logic Remote is free for Apple users, Android users are once again left behind. Logic Pro has been lauded for how easy it is to record live instruments such as vocals, guitars, basses, etc. You have the ability to comp multi-tracks and group them into buses, which makes it very useful when recording something elaborate like a drum kit.

Additionally, the default sound library on Logic Pro is especially useful when recording string instruments because it offers various amp and pedal simulations that you can customize right down to the kind of mic and its placement.

Ableton Live users have complained about the logic pro x or ableton live 10 free of multi-track recording for a while and it is only recently, with Ableton 11, that one can comp tracks.

Ableton Live was initially created for electronic musicians. This means that certain MIDI features on it are exemplary: such as the ability to quickly quantize intricate patterns, control velocity, and edit quickly. But the piano roll leaves more to be desired.

Logic Pro offers a more elaborate piano roll along with a bonus option to view your MIDI notes as a score. This is a very helpful loguc for composers who prefer sheet music over just MIDI information. You can also export your score as a MusicXML file. However, there are plenty plugins that only come in VST versions, particularly when it comes to free plugins or those made by casual or independent plugin makers.

Therefore, if you want to get the maximum amount of plugin compatibility, then Ableton Live is definitely the best option. These include a variety of bass, piano, synth, and experimental sounds.

A highlight of these is that you can customize the parameters to perfection since they emulate analog instruments. Although they can be a little bit tricky to use at first, such as the sampler: a sampling device, they logic pro x or ableton live 10 free a joy to work with if you have a little knowledge of synth hardware.

Logic Pro instruments emulate more organic sounds such as piano and guitar. Although it is recommended one has a basic understanding of music theory to be ab,eton to use these plugins to their fullest potential, it is not necessary. This tool lets you generate a groove automatically, based on the tempo and the time signature of the song. You can then customize these beats based on your preference.

It is a helpful tool for those who are not beatmakers. A cool feature is that you can swap out the sounds on your drum rack. This means that you can mix and match as you want, even add your instrument or effects for either live or recording performances.

There are default s available on their website along with other downloadable ones. You have the option to open these up and see how they work, even customize them if you want. Not only does MAX open up a realm of possibilities for visual artists, but this is very useful for those looking to emulate analog synths digitally or those who have basic knowledge of coding.

Logic Pro only runs on Apple devices. To be able to use the current version, you need macOS It requires a minimum of 3GB of logic pro x or ableton live 10 free space for installation. Mac users need OS You will need 3GB space for installation and an additional 76GB for sound libraries and packs.

Available for free on the app store for logic pro x or ableton live 10 free, iPad, and Mac users, Garageband offers the basics of recording and is a good starting point for those who are not abeton looking to mix and master their tracks by themselves. The interface looks the same as Logic Pro and is very easy to navigate. You can also record instruments or vocals. However, there is a 32 track limit per project. At the end of the logid, Both DAWs have their set of strengths and drawbacks.

While Ableton Live has become known for being a dedicated tool for performing musicians, Logic Pro is well-loved across genres and is used by many musicians to ableeton, record, and og mix and master. So there is no question of which one is better.

It ultimately comes down to what you feel the most comfortable using and which one of these makes your process a smooth one. Also, you do not have to pick just one DAW. Many musicians prefer to use a logic pro x or ableton live 10 free of both.

Some use different DAWs depending on whether they want to write, they want to record or they want to perform live. So take your time and explore both of them, see which one works best for you. Brian Clark is a multi-instrumentalist and music producer. He is passionate about practically all areas of music and he particularly enjoys writing about the music industry. Leave a Logic pro x or ableton live 10 free Leave a reply Cancel reply Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Privacy Policy — About — Contact. Ableton Live Ableton Live comes in 3 different versions. The intro version is logic pro x or ableton live 10 free cheapest, standard version is in the middle, and the suite version is the most expensive.

View Price. Logic Pro. Logic Pro linear kive. View Latest Price. Brian Clark. Related Articles. Can You Run Ableton on an iPad? Leave a Comment. Leave a reply Cancel reply. Leave this field empty.